Hello all, my final blog post with my journal and essay. It’s been fun, hope you enjoy!
The Present and Future of the Digital Humanities in Academia
Compared to the rest of the academic disciplines, the Digital Humanities is a relatively new field. Having existed for only as long as the technology has been around to support it as it continues to evolve. Of course, this is a part of the definition of the Digital Humanities, the use of technology to integrate the humanities in a digital format. However, as with any new discipline, waves are bound to be made throughout the academic community. But what are they? Has the academic community at large accepted and embraced the Digital Humanities, or have they shunned a discipline that has come about in light of a technological revolution of computers and the twenty-first century? The results are quite interesting. A new field in the academic world, the digital humanities have received some justifiable criticism from academia, while others have defended the new discipline by redefining it. The result is a field that obviously will not be going away anytime soon, but may have some growing pains before it really comes into its own in the academic world. To perhaps better understand what these growing pains may be, we must first look at some of the criticisms of the field.
Technology is constantly evolving and changing around us. A year from the now there will be new and improved devices that put the previous to shame. The Digital Humanities have come about through this ever changing and increased use of technology. However, not all are happy about the emergence of this new field. There are those academics who do not believe that the Digital Humanities will bring about any good, and may in fact harm the profession of scholarship. Stanley Fish, professor of humanities and law at the Florida International University is one such individual. In his blog, Fish relates that the digital humanities have changed the relationship between reader and author, that “a desire for pre-eminence, authority, and disciplinary power, is what blogs and the digital humanities stand against” (Fish). More specifically, Fish worries that the digital humanities have eliminated the “lone reader facing a stable text provided by an author who dictates the shape of reading by doling out information in a sequence he controls [and changed it] into a multi-directional experience in which voices (and images) enter, interact and proliferate in ways that decenter the authority of the author who becomes just another participant.” (Fish). These are very harsh claims toward the humanities, but there may be some truth to them. In a digital world where anyone can add or edit information, there is a very real possibility that accurate knowledge could be hard to come by. This is opposed to a stable source from an author that has the credentials and has the evaluation of his peers, something a digital and free format could also lack. Yet this is only one side and perspective of the issue.
While Professor Fish has made his claim with some justifications, not all are entirely opposed to the Digital Humanities. However, it must also be noted that these individuals recognize some of the new disciplines shortcomings. Ted Underwood, an associate professor of English at the University of Illinois is one such individual. For him, the Digital Humanities are not trying to break down barriers of the academic world or “regulating disciplinary boundaries” rather they simply “want a seat at the table” among the others fields (Underwood). Underwood also discusses the reliance on tools that characterizes the Digital Humanities, and how they are not contributing to the destruction of academia. Rather, he tells that the digital tools are simply an evolution of tools that have always been used, and Underwood believes that only now “humanists are consciously taking charge of tools” in order to further their own work, just like any other discipline or researcher (Underwood). In his defense of Digital Humanities Underwood also recognizes that he may have created too broad of a definition. Yet even this he believes is a positive thing for the field, as he believes the Digital Humanities are meant to encompass a wide range of work and projects (Underwood). This display seems to present a more balanced argument for the Digital Humanities. The digital tools that are used in the field are constantly changing, and given the Underwood’s definition that it is an all encompassing field, it only makes sense that the Digital Humanities may take some time before they fit comfortably with the other academic disciplines.
The Digital Humanities are definitely unlike any field or discipline that has entered the academic world up to this point. Taking full advantage of the the ever advancing technology, the field has much potential. However, there are those who fear what they consider to be an aimless and potentially threatening concept to the idea of authorship and academia as a whole. This viewpoint, while not totally irrational and not without its valid criticisms, is not the whole picture. A better view of the Digital Humanities is a new field that seeks to incorporate the projects of the the others, while at the same time working to finds its place among the already well established disciplines. The end result is while there are justifiable fears, the Digital Humanities are not going any where, and with time and self exploration, will not only be worthy to be equal with the other fields, but will cross into, and contribute to those fields. With the pace of increasing technology, it will be interesting to see where the Digital Humanities will go and what its contributions will be.
Annotated Works Cited
Fish, Stanley. “The Digital Humanities and the Transcending of Mortality.” Opinionator: Exclusive Online Commentary from the Times. The New York Times, 09 JAN 2012. Web. 10 Jun. 2012. <http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/01/09/the-digital-humanities- and-the-transcending-of-mortality/>. Stanley Fish, a professor of humanities at Florida International University, writes about how the digital humanities have opened up new doors for the everyday individual and how this may not be good for more traditional scholars such as himself. His belief is that the digital humanities tear down the walls of authority in scholarship, and destroy the authority that an author has in providing information to a reader, if they were to only use a book.
Underwood, Ted. “Why digital humanities isn’t actually “the next thing in literary studies.”.” The Stone and the Shell: Historical questions raised by a quantitative approach to language. N.p., 27 DEC 2011. Web. 10 Jun. 2012. <http://tedunderwood.wordpress.com/2011/12/27/why-we-dont-actually-want-to-be-the- next-thing-in-literary-studies/>. An associate English professor at the University of Illinois, Ted Underwood, describes a very balanced look at the digital humanities. He relates that the Digital Humanities are not in fact a new field, and is a part of the natural evolution of the field.
Journal
-
Browsed through Wright State’s CORE for interviews to use for class project.
-
Selected Elise Kelly’s interview with Sister Maria Francine Stacy
-
Listened through the entire interview and took notes to determine an appropriate subject matter, themes, keywords, etc.
-
Used the notes from the interview to construct an outline. The outline ordered the information by section. These sections were in turn used to create a shell of sections on the web page. The outline contained the paragraphs of my own remarks, as well as a breakdown of the entire interview, with which time ranges would be appropriate for each.
-
Use Wright State University’s STAC center to break up the interview into the desired time ranges.
-
Contacted Sister Stacy and arranged a time to meet.
-
Met with Sister Stacy and acquired several photos of herself and her work. Additionally took several photos of Sister and the surrounding area.
-
Scanned photos into a digital format using resources provided by WSU’s STAC, and edited them as necessary.
-
Uploaded edited audio files and photos to Omeka and arranged them into the shell of the website.
-
Downloaded and broke up the transcript of the interview in order to place them in the appropriate sections of the website.