Journal and Essay

Posted: June 10, 2012 in Uncategorized

Hello all, my final blog post with my journal and essay. It’s been fun, hope you enjoy!

The Present and Future of the Digital Humanities in Academia

Compared to the rest of the academic disciplines, the Digital Humanities is a relatively new field. Having existed for only as long as the technology has been around to support it as it continues to evolve. Of course, this is a part of the definition of the Digital Humanities, the use of technology to integrate the humanities in a digital format. However, as with any new discipline, waves are bound to be made throughout the academic community. But what are they? Has the academic community at large accepted and embraced the Digital Humanities, or have they shunned a discipline that has come about in light of a technological revolution of computers and the twenty-first century? The results are quite interesting. A new field in the academic world, the digital humanities have received some justifiable criticism from academia, while others have defended the new discipline by redefining it. The result is a field that obviously will not be going away anytime soon, but may have some growing pains before it really comes into its own in the academic world. To perhaps better understand what these growing pains may be, we must first look at some of the criticisms of the field.

Technology is constantly evolving and changing around us. A year from the now there will be new and improved devices that put the previous to shame. The Digital Humanities have come about through this ever changing and increased use of technology. However, not all are happy about the emergence of this new field. There are those academics who do not believe that the Digital Humanities will bring about any good, and may in fact harm the profession of scholarship. Stanley Fish, professor of humanities and law at the Florida International University is one such individual. In his blog, Fish relates that the digital humanities have changed the relationship between reader and author, that “a desire for pre-eminence, authority, and disciplinary power, is what blogs and the digital humanities stand against” (Fish). More specifically, Fish worries that the digital humanities have eliminated the “lone reader facing a stable text provided by an author who dictates the shape of reading by doling out information in a sequence he controls [and changed it] into a multi-directional experience in which voices (and images) enter, interact and proliferate in ways that decenter the authority of the author who becomes just another participant.” (Fish). These are very harsh claims toward the humanities, but there may be some truth to them. In a digital world where anyone can add or edit information, there is a very real possibility that accurate knowledge could be hard to come by. This is opposed to a stable source from an author that has the credentials and has the evaluation of his peers, something a digital and free format could also lack. Yet this is only one side and perspective of the issue.

While Professor Fish has made his claim with some justifications, not all are entirely opposed to the Digital Humanities. However, it must also be noted that these individuals recognize some of the new disciplines shortcomings. Ted Underwood, an associate professor of English at the University of Illinois is one such individual. For him, the Digital Humanities are not trying to break down barriers of the academic world or “regulating disciplinary boundaries” rather they simply “want a seat at the table” among the others fields (Underwood). Underwood also discusses the reliance on tools that characterizes the Digital Humanities, and how they are not contributing to the destruction of academia. Rather, he tells that the digital tools are simply an evolution of tools that have always been used, and Underwood believes that only now “humanists are consciously taking charge of tools” in order to further their own work, just like any other discipline or researcher (Underwood). In his defense of Digital Humanities Underwood also recognizes that he may have created too broad of a definition. Yet even this he believes is a positive thing for the field, as he believes the Digital Humanities are meant to encompass a wide range of work and projects (Underwood). This display seems to present a more balanced argument for the Digital Humanities. The digital tools that are used in the field are constantly changing, and given the Underwood’s definition that it is an all encompassing field, it only makes sense that the Digital Humanities may take some time before they fit comfortably with the other academic disciplines.

The Digital Humanities are definitely unlike any field or discipline that has entered the academic world up to this point. Taking full advantage of the the ever advancing technology, the field has much potential. However, there are those who fear what they consider to be an aimless and potentially threatening concept to the idea of authorship and academia as a whole. This viewpoint, while not totally irrational and not without its valid criticisms, is not the whole picture. A better view of the Digital Humanities is a new field that seeks to incorporate the projects of the the others, while at the same time working to finds its place among the already well established disciplines. The end result is while there are justifiable fears, the Digital Humanities are not going any where, and with time and self exploration, will not only be worthy to be equal with the other fields, but will cross into, and contribute to those fields. With the pace of increasing technology, it will be interesting to see where the Digital Humanities will go and what its contributions will be.

Annotated Works Cited

 Fish, Stanley. “The Digital Humanities and the Transcending of Mortality.” Opinionator: Exclusive Online Commentary from the Times. The New York Times, 09 JAN 2012. Web. 10 Jun. 2012. <http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2012/01/09/the-digital-humanities- and-the-transcending-of-mortality/>. Stanley Fish, a professor of humanities at Florida International University, writes about how the digital humanities have opened up new doors for the everyday individual and how this may not be good for more traditional scholars such as himself. His belief is that the digital humanities tear down the walls of authority in scholarship, and destroy the authority that an author has in providing information to a reader, if they were to only use a book.

 Underwood, Ted. “Why digital humanities isn’t actually “the next thing in literary studies.”.” The Stone and the Shell: Historical questions raised by a quantitative approach to language. N.p., 27 DEC 2011. Web. 10 Jun. 2012. <http://tedunderwood.wordpress.com/2011/12/27/why-we-dont-actually-want-to-be-the- next-thing-in-literary-studies/>. An associate English professor at the University of Illinois, Ted Underwood, describes a very balanced look at the digital humanities. He relates that the Digital Humanities are not in fact a new field, and is a part of the natural evolution of the field.

Journal

  • Browsed through Wright State’s CORE for interviews to use for class project.

  • Selected Elise Kelly’s interview with Sister Maria Francine Stacy

  • Listened through the entire interview and took notes to determine an appropriate subject matter, themes, keywords, etc.

  • Used the notes from the interview to construct an outline. The outline ordered the information by section. These sections were in turn used to create a shell of sections on the web page. The outline contained the paragraphs of my own remarks, as well as a breakdown of the entire interview, with which time ranges would be appropriate for each.

  • Use Wright State University’s STAC center to break up the interview into the desired time ranges.

  • Contacted Sister Stacy and arranged a time to meet.

  • Met with Sister Stacy and acquired several photos of herself and her work. Additionally took several photos of Sister and the surrounding area.

  • Scanned photos into a digital format using resources provided by WSU’s STAC, and edited them as necessary.

  • Uploaded edited audio files and photos to Omeka and arranged them into the shell of the website.

  • Downloaded and broke up the transcript of the interview in order to place them in the appropriate sections of the website.

Mining for Data

Posted: June 7, 2012 in Uncategorized

Hello, I’m back with another blog post, this time I’ll be discussing the vast databases of information that exist in our digital world, and how we go about digging through them. The digital world around us has done much good for the academic realm. Thousands of books and other forms of media stored online on digital databases, many of which are easily accessed throughout the world. Yet there is an underlying problem, one which is not so readily apparent. Specifically I’ll be looking at the Digging into Data Challenge, a challenge devised for teams of individuals from around the world, each seeking to ultimately find a better way to dig through the vast databases of information, and along the way learn how research of such databases affects our perception of the digital humanities.

The team in question was working with the Old Baily archive, an extremely large archive of court proceedings from England between 1674-1913. Obviously a massive undertaking, the team decided to use a wide range of tools to provide not only a new way to search and access information, but to bring about new information altogether, a result of the new tools utilized. These tools included Zotero and Voyeur. The team’s work is detailed here, but the end result was quite unlike anything before. Researchers were used to searching by text, while tools like Voyeur encouraged using trends and frequency tables. Nevertheless, the information was able to be presented in a new form. Mathamatica, traditionally a program for engineers even found its way into the project, providing the aforementioned new information in scatter plots and other types of graphs, that in the future could lead to new conclusions.

It is understandable that this challenge would encourage a new way of sifting through the massive amount of data that has accrued in the digital age of the internet. However, the idea that new information, simply brought on by the implementation of new tools, is quite amazing. Though it does make sense that with as much information as there is on the Old Baily archive that this would be possible. Perhaps now areas thought to be long established in information will find new light with new tools.

In closing with this Digital Humanities class, I’d like to share my thoughts on Daniel J. Cohen and Roy Rosenzweig’s Final Thoughts. Bot are of the belief that the digital world around us has presented us with an opportunity to create, and to preserve, but jumping into the digital world. They caution against getting in too quickly, advising review by others, and obviously following all that they related about more technical and legal aspects of putting your site and information out on the site. Yet, they also believe that while there will fears and apprehension about putting yourself out there, there will always be the opportunity to edit and revise. I whole heartily agree with their message. With a medium as accessible as the internet, it is vital to ensure that information is recorded, preserved, and presented in an accurate and pleasing fashion. Those of us who pursue this end had the responsibility of not only taking advantage of this medium, but preserving the information of our own time for future generations.

 

 

 

The Dangers of Wikipedia

Posted: June 7, 2012 in Uncategorized

Hello all, another blog post here. Today I’ll be discussing wikipedia.org, the online user created and edited encyclopedia. In particular, I’ll be looking at the potentially disastrous uses of Wikipedia, from the editing of biographies to the idea of truth versus verifiability. However, there are seemingly positive aspects as well, where Wikipedia has been taken in as a teaching tool of sorts, in this case taking advantage of Wikipedia’s ease of user editing to create purposeful hoax. However, I will first focus on what would be considered the most dangerous of Wikipedia’s uses, that of editing the biographies of living persons.

One of wikipedia’s allures is the ease in which anyone can create or edit an article about anything on the site. However, this can have dangerous implications, specifically in the case of the biographies of living persons. One such incident involved John Seigenthaler, an American journalist who found his biography on Wikipedia altered. Within his bio it stated that he had once been involved in the Kennedy assassination, which was completely false. Seigenthaler was able to get the article corrected after a lengthy amount of time, but it does leave a dangerous precedent. The entry had been up for four months before it was brought to Seigenthaler’s attention. Who’s to say there aren’t other individuals with potentially erroneous biographies, that will be taken as fact? It is a dangerous precedent, and an obvious reason why Wikipedia is not to be cited academically.

Thankfully, Wikipedia does edit themselves. In my own search, I looked up former President George W. Bush. The history was littered with revisions. One in particular I found (be warned, there is foul language) was clearly using Wikipedia to simply insult the President. While this is an extreme case, the rest of the revision history page did show many edits that were also changed or removed for structuring, word use, and the more subtle bias within the article. In this way I would credit Wikipedia for being as diligent as possible with their articles. Thankfully, now after the incident with John Seigenthaler’s bio, biographies on Wikipedia are semi-protected from edits.

In a more positive light, Wikipedia has been put to academic use. Not in the sense of using it for citations, rather it was used as the platform for a class. In it the professor instructed his students to create a fictitious student who was to research the additionally fictitious historical figure Edward Owens, an American pirate. The hoax was successful, up until the professor decided to bring the affair to light. He believed that the class had taught student to be more careful in their own research, adopt some digital experience, as well as have fun. The class as a whole obviously explore Wikipedia’s faults, but it also presents a dangerous possibility. Given enough time and effort, and large group of people could literally change history, and the flow of information, by creating a convincing enough entry on Wikipedia, given the sites high traffic and the ease with which many people take Wikipedia’s information as academically factual.

This flows right into the “gatekeeper” role that Wikipedia flies in the face of. Prior to Wikipedia’s creation, the academic world controlled the evaluation of and presenting of information. Now that has changed, as NPR radio discussed in their interview with two authors, Timothy Messer-Kruse and Andrew Lih. In the interview they discuss how Messer-Kruse, an author on the Haymarket Bombing in 1986 attempted to edit an article on the matter on Wikipedia. He wished to make corrections to the article because he had primary sources that supported his position, yet his edit was rejected. The issue came down to that Wikipedia is about verifiability, not truth, and that the sources provided by Messer-Kruse were to obscure, and needed secondary authorship to verify. Lih provided the insight that Wikipedia relies much on the popularly accepted concept, namely that Messer-Kruse’s sources may have been accurate, but that had not filtered to the general public yet, and thus could not be verified for their authenticity.

How strange. Normally primary sources are paramount in original research and backing up a statement. Yet the opposite is true with Wikipedia. It can only use what “could” be popularly considered true, as opposed to what is. This is very dangerous. Academics in this arena are no longer the “gatekeepers” of knowledge, the masses who access and edit Wikipedia are. And because of its ease of use, it makes the website all the more scary. Nevertheless, Wikipedia as a whole should not be completely vilified. I completely believe that the site is an excellent tool for background information and a good way to find sources, provided they are there. In the end I would stick with, use Wikipedia as much as you want, just don’t cite it. You never know what outlandish information may be on the screen.

(Journal added for best blog post)

HST 488 Journal

  • Browsed through Wright State’s CORE for interviews to use for class project.

  • Selected Elise Kelly’s interview with Sister Maria Francine Stacy

  • Listened through the entire interview and took notes to determine an appropriate subject matter, themes, keywords, etc.

  • Used the notes from the interview to construct an outline. The outline ordered the information by section. These sections were in turn used to create a shell of sections on the web page. The outline contained the paragraphs of my own remarks, as well as a breakdown of the entire interview, with which time ranges would be appropriate for each.

  • Use Wright State University’s STAC center to break up the interview into the desired time ranges.

  • Contacted Sister Stacy and arranged a time to meet.

  • Met with Sister Stacy and acquired several photos of herself and her work. Additionally took several photos of Sister and the surrounding area.

  • Scanned photos into a digital format using resources provided by WSU’s STAC, and edited them as necessary.

  • Uploaded edited audio files and photos to Omeka and arranged them into the shell of the website.

  • Downloaded and broke up the transcript of the interview in order to place them in the appropriate sections of the website.

Hello all, here again with another update. You’ll have to excuse the lateness of this blog post; school work has really ramped up, and will unfortunately remain so throughout the rest of the quarter. But enough of that.

Today I’ve found a pair of items that I found very intriguing. I first is similar in concept to the “pseudo” 3D effect that I showed last time using the Kinect devices. The second is a very useful organization tool, that I think any of us will be able to appreciate, since I’m sure we’ve all been had to do some research at some point or another.

The first is, in my opinion, the next evolution of graphic interface with many different types of tech. It’s called Leap Motion, and it brings a whole new level of control between the user and the device. Instead of a touchscreen, the technology uses spatial and motion sensing, much like Microsoft’s Kinect. However, this device is much more sensitive, and incorporates more abilities. One very simple, yet profound ability in my mind was the importing of the “pinch to zoom” feature found now on most touch screens. There is still no physical contact, rather Leap Motion recognizes the interaction of the index finger with another, the result is zooming in and out just by pinching in front of the screen. There are of course a whole range of controls that you would expect to navigate on screen. Think “Minority Report” just without the hand device. The device’s application though is really where it will though. Engineers will be able to construct complex models in 3D, graphs and statistics will gain a new level of depth, and of course gaming won’t be far behind. Even better is the developers intent to allow third party developers an open use with the technology, in order to populate what is sure to become a wide range of useful apps.

My second tool falls into the realm of academia. We all have (or are) done research at some point. I know just recently that my work on a relatively large history paper turned out a plethora of information. That’s where Evernote comes in. Its goal is to aid students in organizing quotes and sources, with the help of tags and keywords. You can even “clip” a part of a webpage, and Evernote will store it with useful information, like the URL. What I found most impressive though is the sharing ability between users with the program. What better way to find a source than through someone else who has already found it? Lastly, the program, like many others today, stores all its files on a cloud, so you can access your info where ever you can get on the Internet.

Hello again everyone, Mike Hughes here with another blog post. Today I’ve got my thoughts on several history sites and their alternative forms of presenting information, whether by video or interactive game. I’ve also got some more information of where I’m heading with my webpage. But first, the history sites.

The first site I looked at was called playinghistory.org which provided numerous links to history websites with interactive games. In this fashion the site itself functions like a hub; the site does not actually have any of its own games, instead acting as a central pool to gather other sites together in one place. The homepage is slightly unorthodox. The first thing that jumps out is the tag pool, filled with links to various subjects in various sizes, depending on their overall popularity. The rest of the page is dedicated to showcasing the games. Upon clicking upon a game, a link is provided to the site; however there is also a review system in place for users to rate the games. The two games that I played were A Day in the Life, and Majority Rules. The first dealt with presenting real historical judicial situations to students, who then had to pick the correct corresponding Supreme Court case title. While simple, the game provided not only information around the case, but used them in such a way so that students could see that major court cases have and do affect our daily lives. The second also dealt with judicial activities, and also presented a detailed situation that led to a historic court case. However, in this case, the object was to choose the correct opinion, as written by the majority and dissenting judges on the bench. Regardless of choice the game would provide not only the immediate effects of the court case, but often follow it up with long term consequences.

The second site I viewed is called Rome Reborn, a website dedicated to rebuilding ancient Rome from its origins up through to the Middle Ages, using digital construction tools. The site hosts video and pictures of their work, as well as archives of older and previous work in order to showcase their progress. To bolster their credibility, there are several papers that have been written about the site and their work. While the site is impressive, it does not seem to have been updated since 2010. Nevertheless, it is still an impressive piece of historical work.

Moving on toward my project, I’ve nearly completed my draft of my script. I’ve finished a detailed outline, which has broken down times from the interview with Sister Maria Francine Stacy, which are grouped accordingly with the proper page section. My own thoughts in text form will also be arranged this way, along with photos. I have scheduled to see Sister Stacy this week, as well as go to her parish to get the appropriate photos. I will have to eliminate a good deal when it comes to the audio clips, especially for the third page, but at this point I’m glad I have a good deal to choose from. Hopefully I’ll have all this wrapped up before the end of the week, though there is much to do in my other studies.

Hello all. I’ve decided what I hope will not only be the format (pending any over all changes we may decide to make), as well as the content for my project. Just a little refresher; my interview is with Sister Maria Francine Stacy, which describes her background, time in college, her ultimate calling to religious life, and finally her move to work with immigrants. I’ve decided to break up my portion along these lines, using each of Sister Maria’s stages of life as a mini section so to speak.While highlighting her own work, I will also be writing my own reactions, as I am a Catholic, and I want to provide my viewpoint on the matter along side her own work.

The first section will be brief, only giving an outline of her early life, obviously providing the sound clips from that portion of the audio log. For myself, I will provide my thoughts on religious life when I was younger, how I viewed them etc. I was taught many things by my parents, and I want to provide how my view and/or thoughts evolved as I grew older.

The next section will deal with her college life, again mostly brief with a selection from the interview. For myself, this section will highlight my own evolving views, as I am still currently in college. Depending on how long these portions end up being, I may include Sister Maria’s entry into religious life within this section. From here we get to the real meat of my project.

Following the previous section will either be Sister Maria’s entry into religious life, or her move toward a more activist role as a Catholic Nun. Assuming the later, this section will more than likely be the largest, with the maximum two minutes sound bytes from the interview, and a large portion of text and my own reaction. My reaction will largely be my views on Sister Maria’s work; in that it is not something that is brought to light when people, even a Catholic like myself, see or think of the religious in the Catholic Church. Many think this type of work is more fitting or suited to a country outside the United States, but this is not the case.

To wrap up what I’ve envisioned, I would like to add pictures to the page, but with my work load and time constraints, I may not be able to get to the Church were Sister Maria worked from. However, I believe that simple images of religious items (crucifix, saints, etc.) could still be used in context of my project. These pictures I could take easily within my own home. Additionally, depending on the content, I may decide to split up the section for their own pages; I don’t want anything to get too crowded. I believe the overall layout will largely mimic what we decided on last Monday. Any suggestions are appreciated.

 

Hello everyone, returning with another blog entry. I’m going to be talking about another chapter from our text, which deals with copyrights. Though definitely not the most savory subject, the information from this reading does provide us with some valuable insight, and will help us avoid any infringements as we work. Also, I’ll relating here (and in class) what I’ve found as far as plugins from Omeka. Most are very basic, but interesting enough they fulfill much of what we’ve discussed about. But first, the reading.

This week’s reading dealt with the facts and issues surrounding the copyright. Entitled Owning the Past, in Daniel J. Cohen and Ron Rosenzweig’s Digital History a Guide to Gathering, Preserving, and Presenting the Past on the Web, the chapter details the development of copyright, protecting intellectual property, fair use, as well as other facets of pertaining to copyright. By and large, the text made it clear that copyright has favored the owner as time has gone on; in some instances copyright is retained for the life of the author, plus fifty years following their death. Pertaining to our own uses, copyright will largely still be in effect with many sources that we may wish to use. Perhaps more important to us will be the “fair use” tenet that exists. Fair use allows persons to borrow a limited amount from a work, as long as it produces “something new and useful”, which for our purposes will be extremely useful. The term does seem to be a little vague, which the text does admit. However, we should not be too worried about incurring any penalties. The text states that historians face a very slim chance of being sued, as most owners are more content with the offender removing the source from a site, something that is thankfully very easy to do. Perhaps even more reason not to fear consequences is that fact that if we are too cautious and do not exercise our legitimate right to fair use, then it very well may wither and die from disuse. The text also gives a good overview of special kinds of sources, such as photo copies of art or prints, and the very complicated issue of music, though we will more than likely not have to deal with that matter. In short, we should be well aware of copyright, but not so much that it restricts us from our right to contribute “something new and useful”.

On the topic of being creative, I now turn to Omeka.org‘s plugins that I was assigned to explore. Imagine my surprise when many of them came very close to fulfilling many of our objectives that we outlined in previous classes! While I’m not sure if we will be able to use them all, this compiled list that I’ve come up with should provide us with a good selection. They are as follows:

  • Commenting
  • Contribution
  • Docs Viewer
  • Exhibit Builder
  • Geolocation
  • Image Annotation
  • Image Resize
  • Simple Contact Form
  • Social Bookmarking
  • Terms of Service
  • Timeline
  • Zotero Import

I believe that these will be extremely useful for our work. I’ll be elaborating on them more in class. Thanks for reading!

Hello all, its been a little while, but I’ve gotten back to my blog, something that will be a much more regular occurrence. I took some time to look over the suggested websites from this past week, and I took a particular interest in the sites dedicated to cataloging the experiences, art, stories, video, audio, and just about everything in between that has come as a result of 9/11.

The first of the two is the September 11 Digital Archive, which covers much of the material that I have mentioned above. It has more than 150,000 digital items, which made it the largest digital archive that was accepted into the Library of Congress. What is interesting about the archive though is its wide range of material that can be viewed. Everything from stories and interview to images and email are recorded. But this is not a static archive. It is constantly increasing. The site readily takes submissions from users, who can submit any kind of medium. Having recently read through the chapter Designing for the History Web from Digital History: A Guide to Gathering, Preserving and Presenting the Past on the Web by Daniel J Cohen and Roy Rosenzweig, I could better analyze the effective layout and build of the website. The site uses a basic two tone color scheme of white and blue, while effectively placing a faded picture of Ground Zero in the background. Navigation is also simple to use and access. All the major links are placed in a header bar at the top of the screen, each leading to an appropriately organized page according to the subject matter. The browse tab is especially effective in this, leading to a neat page of links each sub-divided by headers. The second website, Witness and Response: September 11 Acquisitions at the Library of Congress deals in very much the same material, although from what I could find it did not have an option for visitors to submit their own accounts. Additionally, while the site is organized, the various links around the site are bare and don’t really have any kind of unifier like a tab or bar. Nevertheless, the site does keep things simple with colors: utilizing black, grey and red to accentuate the tone of the site. Overall both are effective at what they do in recording such a tragic moment in our nation’s history.

Of my own material, I have selected the CORE interview of Catholic Nun Sister Maria Francine Stacy and her work in activism. She tells a great deal about her time before becoming a Nun, her decision to become one, and her sub sequential work in schools and activism. I’m thinking about high-lighting her own activism with perhaps other ideas of Catholic activism, but I’m still developing that idea. As far as a future structure for my page, I may gather some pictures either of the Campus Ministry here at WSU, or even my Parish back home. There are also groups that work within both parishes, so I may explore information of possible activism that both contribute. In my mind it would make a good parallel to Sister Stacy’s own story.

As far our own in class activities, I have discovered two items in particular that might be of some interest. While I don’t want to spoil everything for my lightning presentation Monday, I will say that one is an online collaborative workspace sharing tool, and the other is an excellent source of online historical data. I look forward to explaining it to everyone Monday.

Hello all, my name is Michael Hughes. I’d like to welcome you all to my first blog, and my first blog post. I will be using this blog to detail my thoughts, experiences and work with History and New Media. But before I get into that, I’d like to introduce myself a little more.

I’m a Senior at Wright State University, in (hopefully) my final quarter. I’m a history major, as well as an MSIV Army ROTC Cadet, planning on commissioning as a 2LT upon graduation. I’ve always enjoyed history, thought it can be a lot of work. This class, HST 488 History and New Media is definitely a course that I am unfamiliar with, though I look forward working in a class that has a more applied history focus. As such I’m still getting used to using a blog and thinking about history through a different medium, but I have confidence that I will learn and contribute what I can.

From the first reading assignment in Digital History: A Guide to Gathering, Preserving, and Presenting the Past on the Web by Daniel J Cohen and Roy Rosenzweig, it surprised me how the internet has changed how we access, store, and work with history. Having grown up with the internet, I did not have the privilege of witnessing the transition and the fears of those older individuals. I am happy that most of their fears did not come to pass, though I may be somewhat biased in favor of the internet and its usefulness. It was interesting to read on the early days, and how the various historians took it upon themselves to set up their own websites, and benefit their peers through greater access. However, the internet and its utility as an ease of access tool brought a few problems with it. A victim of its own popularity, there simply was too much information; too many sites, and the difficulty of ascertaining whether a source was scholarly or not, something I can sympathize with. Thankfully, reputable sites, like those set up by the Smithsonian and the Library of Congress, have helped remedy this dilemma. I was further amazed by the The American Memory and Making America, which have opened up a whole new wealth of knowledge that was previously much more difficult to access. In my mind, it really does justify that the utility of the internet has more pros than cons, and has benefited professional, amateur, and students of history alike.